Categories
Forex Market Analysis

Microeconomics and Macroeconomics: Are They Necessary In Forex Trading?

If we want to take our Forex trading to a higher level, it is necessary to have some knowledge of microeconomics and macroeconomics. Perhaps the macroeconomic aspects are more relevant for the trader, but here we will show you everything you at least need to know about both disciplines.

Many people who approach the world of Forex or the financial markets in general wonder if they have the right preparation to carry out such activity and some wonder if it is necessary to have a university degree or studies in economics to be able to trade in a market like Forex.

In reality, online broker platforms open the doors to everyone, but having the possibility to invest a certain capital in a particular market is simply an opportunity: does not in any way mean that more specialised knowledge or information can be dispensed with.

On the other hand, a short-term operation like most that takes place in the various currency markets tends to be influenced to a large extent by what happens in the world. 

For example, news about a country’s politics makes its currency more or less stable.

But what is Microeconomics?

Microeconomics analyses the decisions of individuals and different economic agents in a theoretical way. This discipline proposes simplified models of reality in order to understand the implications of personal decisions and how to decide.

Is Microeconomics the Economy of the Small?

Not exactly, Microeconomics studies the decisions of the different economic agents from the individual point of view. For example, Microeconomics analyses the decisions of companies, large or small.

How does Microeconomics analyze decisions?

Microeconomics connects the objectives of economic agents with their possibilities. These economic actors will try to achieve their objectives to the maximum extent possible, but bearing in mind that other economic actors will also try to do the same.

What kind of economic agents study microeconomics?

Microeconomics studies the decisions of both individuals and groups as a family, a company, an association… Thus, for example, it stops at the decisions of the State, but also at those of individuals who make decisions within the State.

What forms of expression does Microeconomics use?

It uses three forms of expression: the intuitive way of expressing itself through spoken or written words, the graphical form, and the use of mathematics.

Intuitive: Analyzes decisions through discourse, offering greater proximity to unfamiliar audiences. It has a didactic interest since what is understood either graphically or mathematically must be explained.

Graphs: Very useful when making comparisons and understanding the effects of a certain type of situation on the decisions of individuals.

Mathematics: They are a tool for calculating, but above all for thinking. They provide rigor and conciseness, favoring the analysis of how many factors influence decisions. Many discourses can be replaced with an equation.

Does Microeconomics Help to Understand the Financial World?

Much, more every day. Finance involves many decisions such as how much to save and how much to consume, what to invest in, or how to cover that risk. It also provides tools to understand the strategies that occur in the interrelationship of the actors involved in the financial system.

What about the company world?

One of the growing interests of Microeconomics is to understand the decisions of all kinds that take place in the company. Aspects such as commercial, financial, human resources decisions, etc.

What is the macroeconomy?

Macroeconomics analyses and studies the overall functioning of the economy, in order to explain the evolution of economic aggregates.

What is macroeconomics good for?

Macroeconomics is useful because it allows us to analyse how best to achieve a country’s economic objectives. Economic policy is the tool that governments have to achieve these goals. Objectives such as achieving price stability, achieving economic growth, promoting employment, and maintaining a sustainable and balanced balance of payments.

Some questions we can ask ourselves…

– What are the data that usually have the greatest impact on financial markets?

-Could an increase in consumer prices affect currencies and other instruments?

-Why is economic growth important to investors around the world?

An important part of the fundamental analysis is related to the publication of macroeconomic data. While some indicators have a greater impact than others, the publication of data that takes the market by surprise – either by being published in advance or by exceeding expectations – can cause considerable market volatility.

Employment, the pulse of an economy

Probably the most relevant indicator of an economy’s health is the employment figure. This is because employment directly influences all aspects of economic activity, from supply to demand.

Unemployment rates inform us of the percentage of the total workforce that is unemployed but active in employment and willing to work. A steady rise in unemployment levels is a manifestation of the country’s deteriorating economic situation, negatively perceived by financial markets as a signal to withdraw from the currency. Normally, the market concludes that the higher the level of unemployment, the weaker the currency.

Non-Farm Payroll (NFP)

One of the most important data with the greatest impact on markets is the non-agricultural payroll of the United States. Non-agricultural payrolls are released every first Friday of the month and inform us of new jobs in all sectors except agriculture, as well as the unemployment rate of the previous month.

Given that consumers account for approximately 70 percent of a country’s economic activity, the state of the labour market is of vital importance for the generation of the overall well-being of countries. An improvement in the NFP data indicates that the US labor market is strengthening, improving the outlook for the US economy, and therefore a positive effect on the US dollar.

Inflation, the key to central bank decisions

The main objective of central banks is to promote price stability in the economy. Price stability is measured as inflation changes, so investors monitor inflation reports to determine the future course of central bank policies.

CPI is probably the most important indicator of inflation

Here we are talking about a statistical estimate calculated on the basis of the use of prices of a significant sample of representative products whose prices are collected on a regular basis. The CPI simply measures the rise in the prices of goods and services and is calculated for different categories and subcategories.

If the publication of the CPI is above expectations, this means that inflation pressure is high and the central bank could raise interest rates, which could lead to an increase in the value of the currency.

In general, central banks try to counteract an increase in inflation with higher interest rates, which can lead to a strengthening of currencies. A low inflation rate on the other hand is offset by lower interest rates, which can lead to a weakening of the currency.

GDP – the true color of an economy

It is the largest indicator of a country’s economy and shows the total market value of all services and goods produced in a given year. Impacts of GDP on personal finance, investment, and employment growth. Investors look at the growth rate of a country or economy to decide whether to adjust their asset allocation. They also compare countries’ growth rates with each other to decide where the best opportunities might be. This strategy includes the purchase of shares of companies in fast-growing countries.

When you start in the world of negotiation and trade, it is very convenient to focus on the indicators we have mentioned before, before you want to move forward and delve into other data such as consumer confidence, business surveys, or even retail sales.

Categories
Forex Economic Indicators

What Is Gross Domestic Product (GDP) & How Is It Useful For The Forex Traders?

Introduction

Gross Domestic Product, also known as GDP, is one of the main Microeconomic Indicator in Forex. It is the total amount of money spent on final goods and services. GDP is expressed in percentage terms and is calculated across different time periods. The time period is usually from one quarter to another.

It is a standard measure for the value added to the country’s economy through the production of goods and services during a specific time period. GDP is published by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and information on the same can be found on their official website.

What does GDP measure?

Just as explained in the beginning, GDP measures the health of an economy. If the GDP of a country is high, it means it is receiving capital flows from central banks and institutions, which is a big positive for that country. However, if the GDP numbers are declining quarter on quarter, it means the economic growth of the country is shrinking. When GDP falls, unemployment in the country rises, and output in production drops.

GDP is important because it gives a birds-eye view of how the economy is doing. It is a sign of people getting more jobs, getting better pay, and businesses feeling confident about investing more.

Calculation of GDP

The GDP of a country can be calculated by using the below-mentioned formula

GDP = C + I + G + (X-M)

Where C is the spending made by consumers

I is the investment by businesses

G is the government spending

(X-M) is the net exports

How do Forex traders use GDP?

GDP is an indicator that is used by both technical and fundamental traders. It is one of the most critical drivers of the economy and is closely monitored by all. GDP is important because it can affect how the financial markets can behave, both positively and negatively. Strong GDP growth translates into higher corporate earnings, which directly appreciates the currency value. Conversely, falling GDP means the economy is weakening, which is negative for the currency and, therefore, stock prices. According to economists, a recession is said to occur when there are two consecutive quarters of negative GDP growth.

One should not forget that GDP is a lagging indicator, meaning it shows what the economy did in the past. It does not predict the state of the economy in the near future. Hence, if the GDP data of a country is not good, traders view this as an opportunity to buy the currency and make a profit in the long term.

Summary

Understanding the Gross Domestic Product and its growth rate is essential for investors and traders as it affects the decision-making process of policymakers of the country. When the GDP growth rate is high, the central banks raise interest rates and encourage investment. High-interest rate is said to attract foreign investors and financial institutions. With the improvement in research and quality of data, statisticians and governments are trying to find measures to strengthen GDP and make it a comprehensive indicator of national income.

Categories
Forex Market Analysis

Bring the Quarterly Results In

Weekly Update (July 16th – 20th)

Macroeconomic Outlook

Among all the uncertain variables that have been defining the markets, which are protectionism, oil and politics, I would like to focus on oil.

  • In the last days, oil prices have fallen 5%
    • This has had really good repercussions, both in the micro and macroeconomy
      • From the macro view
        • The July CIP will not be under pressure that much and we will see whether it approaches the 2% target by Central banks
      • From the micro view
        • Lower energy costs will represent an increase in the profit per share
      • Therefore, these three variables have lost intensity and the immediate conclusion is that it is positive for the markets. In the short term

In the short term, two new variables surge,

  • On one hand, quarterly results
    • Throughout this week more quarterly results of 72 companies will be released in the USA and corporate results are expected to increase by 21%
    • At the same time, in 2019 and 2020, the growth figures are around 10%
      • In the end, indexes replicate the increase of corporate results
    • Regarding Europe, growth will be more modest
      • 2018 – 9%
      • 2019 / 2019 – 8%
        • In general, corporate results will sustain growth
      • On the other hand, employment volume is expected to decrease a little until the 15th of August
        • After that date, the bullish path will be resumed
      • As a conclusion, these two variables will influence the markets in a positive way

Moving to this week, there are no relevant macroeconomic indicators that will influence the markets too much. Nevertheless, even though they are forecasted to be weak, they are still better than the previous ones.

Categories
Forex Educational Library

Macroeconomic Projections of the United States

In the course of 2017, the projections of the Federal Reserve almost did not change due to the good performance of the labour market. Good figures in the creation of jobs added to a modest but solid economic growth throughout the year. This article will present the macroeconomic projections that the Federal Reserve had for 2017 and for the following years, and how some of these were modified during the meetings.

At the September meeting, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) decided to keep the interest rate unchanged at 1.25%. It was decided to leave the rate unchanged in order to continue encouraging the accommodative policy and for the labour market to continue strengthening. In addition, inflation did not show positive behaviour throughout 2017 so the committee decided to wait to see if inflation accelerated in the last quarter of the year.

Also at the September meeting, it was decided to start the normalisation policy of the balance sheet in October, reducing the securities holdings by the bank in a gradual and predictable manner so as not to affect the market.

According to Yellen’s statements in September the committee observed a moderate but solid growth of the US economy, a labour market with very low unemployment rates that boosted household wealth, which translated into good consumption figures. Business investments accelerated in the third quarter and exports showed strength in September, having a good performance reflecting the good economic conditions of 2017.

The committee was aware that the results of the third quarter were going to show a slight deceleration due to natural disasters occurring mid-year, but after the third quarter, a rebound was expected in economic activity. This would be due to the resumption of activities of industries in the affected districts. In August the unemployment rate was 4.4%, core inflation excluding volatile goods such as food and energy categories was low and far from showing signs of complying with the inflation rate of the committee.

However, the committee believed that the causes that kept inflation low were transitory as competition in mobile telephony or in general, globalisation that generated fierce competition and therefore prices in many markets had a downward trend. Hurricanes, despite having caused material damage and affecting the population in several districts, were a boost for inflation because fuel prices increased due to damage to refineries and platforms.

In September, the projections that the Federal Reserve had for 2017 were:

  • Real GDP: 2.4%.
  • Unemployment: 4.3%.
  • Inflation 1.6%.

 

Compared to the June projections, the committee slightly changed the projections of real GDP due to the greater strength of the economy, but inflation projections were reduced because it softened its behaviour in the second quarter and beginning of the third quarter.

In the following graph you can see the projections for 2017 and for the next three years:

Graph 46. Economic projections of Federal Reserve Board members and Federal Reserve Bank presidents under their individual assessments of projected appropriate monetary policy, September 2017. Retrieved 19th January 2018 from https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/fomcprojtabl20170920.pdf

As you can see the expected economic growth in 2017 is above the long-term growth estimated by the reserve. The unemployment rate is below the long-term natural rate, but there were no changes compared to the estimate in June and inflation is below the 2% target, and was revised downwards due to its weak performance during 2017.

In Yellen’s comments, it was stated that the 1.25% interest rate was below the projected interest rate to be long-term, so it remained an expansionary rate. The average rate expected by the committee on federal funds was 1.4% at the end of 2017, 2.1% for 2018, 2.7% for 2019 and 2.9% for 2020.

From October through to December, the committee expected to reduce its holdings of securities to a ceiling of $6 billion dollars per month for treasury bonds and $4 billion per month for agencies. These specified ceilings were taken as a restriction for investors to accommodate their expectations in accordance with the normalisation of the balance sheet.

Finally, the committee commented that its main tool to modify the monetary policy was the intervention of the interest rate of the federal funds. The normalisation of the balance sheet was not seen as an active reserve tool, but, if it was observed, a deterioration of the economy they could reverse or limit the normalisation of the balance sheet.

At the December meeting, the FOMC decided to raise the interest rate up to 1.5%. The decision was made after seeing a very good second and third quarter of the economy in contrast to a first quarter where the activity was slow. Household spending, business investment and exports were important aspects of economic activity in order to have this positive behaviour. The committee expected that the tax cuts would encourage economic activity in the future, but the magnitude and exact timing of the macroeconomic effects of the tax reform was not clear.

The unemployment rate stood at 4.1% in November and was below the expectations of the committee and the expected long-term rate. The committee expected that positive behaviour throughout the 2017 labour market, with a high number of jobs created and improvements in salaries due to the narrow job offer. In the future, it was expected that the behaviour would continue to be positive but not at such high rates due to the increase in interest rates, and the normalisation of the balance sheet, policies that would remove liquidity from the economy in general.

Despite this positive performance of the economy and the labour market, inflation remained below the 2% long-term goal of the committee. Core inflation in October was 1.4%, so it was far from the target, but the committee still believed that the causes of low inflation was transitory and had nothing to do with anything structural in the economy.

The following graph shows the projections that the Federal Reserve had and its modifications with respect to those that were in September.

Graph 47. Economic projections of Federal Reserve Board members and Federal Reserve Bank presidents under their individual assessments of projected appropriate monetary policy, December 2017. Retrieved 19th January 2018 from https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/fomcprojtabl20171213.pdf

Compared to the September projections of the real growth of the economy, projections rose not only for 2017 but also for the next three years. The unemployment rate change saw its projections reduced, moving away from the long-term figure. The projections of inflation remained almost unchanged, but showing that not until 2019 would it reach the goal of the Federal Reserve. For most of the members of the committee, it is clear that the tax reform will boost economic growth, but the magnitude was still unclear due to the fact that there is much uncertainty in most macroeconomic variables after this reform.

With these expectations on the growth of the following years, the committee guaranteed several increases of the interest rate in these following years, but specify that there is not much room left to have neutral rates because historically the current rates are lower, so it is not far off for the neutral level in the rates. That is, in the long term the committee expected to have lower rates than the rates that have been historically established. The projections on the interest rate are 2.1% for 2018, 2.7% for 2019 and 3.1% for 2020.

Additionally, the committee stated that the normalisation of the balance sheet was in progress since October. For Janet Yellen, the president of the Federal Reserve system has only the January meeting left when she will be relieved by Jay Powell, so December’s was the last scheduled press conference by her.

In conclusion, we see an economy growing solidly during the last three quarters, with a healthy job market and good salaries. The only negative aspect that has been observed in the meetings is the behaviour and the projections that they have on inflation because it has softened its trend in recent months, which shows that it is probably not transitory causes that have low inflation. It cannot be ruled out that the causes are structural, affecting in the future the projections of the monetary policy of the United States, so the reserve should be cautious in its next meetings.

Categories
Forex Educational Library

Macroeconomics and its Limitations

 Abstract

Macroeconomics is the basis of the fundamental analysis of investors who analyse how an economy is, what are its most prosperous sectors and how is its regulation to make sure that their investment will be profitable. Although macroeconomics includes many models, it still has shortcomings that do not make it entirely reliable. Even with these restrictions, it’s a necessary tool when making decisions to invest.

There are many unknown variables in current economies, and there are questions like why some countries grow more than others, why inflation varies from year to year, why all countries suffer from crises and recessions, which measures can be taken by local governments to reduce the frequency and the magnitude of these events. Macroeconomics is the branch of the economy that tries to solve all these questions that are related to the economy of a country.

To appreciate the importance of macroeconomics, it is best to read newspapers daily or listen to the news.  Every day we see headlines related to the economy, central bank measures, trade agreements with other countries, the unemployment rate, and many others. Although many people are not interested in these issues, it is important to be updated as all these variables affect the lives of all people. For workers and independent people, the Central Banks decisions are significant, as they influence their consumption. Also, these measures determine the levels of investment in industries and commerce.

As the state of the economy affects all people, macroeconomics is a subject that plays a central role in political debates. In the elections of president, governors, and senators it is important that people give the necessary importance to choose who would be a good governor depending on their economic proposals. Other proposals of social and political reforms also matter, but economics is not a minor issue when choosing the right candidate.

It is normal that the popularity of a president would grow when the economy performs satisfactorily, and fall in the polls when crises occur and the unemployment rate increases. But macroeconomic issues are not only an important issue at a local level. There are meetings between leaders and world politicians to carry out joint policies among several countries so that the benefit is mutual, and development is equitable.

Although the world leaders have the job of devising and executing the measures that concern the economy, the work of developing models and explaining what the effects of those policies are is the work of the macroeconomists. To examine the models, macroeconomists must collect information on production, prices, unemployment and other variables from different time periods and several countries. The theoretical models, although they are not fully accurate, are a good tool to determine the effects of monetary policies, fiscal policies, international trade, among other measures, that the authorities can take.

The truth is that macroeconomics is an imperfect and young science. Since historical data is used to test the models, predictions about the future can often be wrong, economic conditions are never the same in two different periods of time. But with the development of several models in the last 50 years, the effect of some measures is clear such as increased public spending or tax reduction. What is often not well known is its magnitude.

Each era has its economic problems. In certain years between 1970 and 1980, some countries had problems with their inflation rates that were extremely high, while the opposite is happening in recent years, experiencing extremely weak inflation rates that do not allow central banks to execute policies that could stimulate higher growth in the economy. In 2007, there was a global financial crisis that lasted for several years. A financial juncture from which some countries still did not have recovered. There have been collapses in the stock markets, as well as the one that happened in the year 2000, when stock values went well above their fair value, especially in the technology sector.

As each epoch has its problems and different political and social conjunctures, it is difficult for macroeconomics to make accurate predictions about the variables in the future because contingencies will always arise. The historical facts of macroeconomics provide incentives to new models to explain past events and predict what may happen in the future. But the basic principles of macroeconomics do not vary in years or decades; there are specific rules that must be followed to model according to the data to which the analysts have to get accustomed.

While the models are far from reality, they are made in a simple way to be more understandable, and often a simple model that explains historical facts is better because a complicated model that takes more time to elaborate, ends up explaining the same thing as the simple model. The models have two kinds of variables, endogenous and exogenous. The endogenous variables are the variables that the model tries to explain, and the exogenous variables come as assumptions to the model, which are taken as true and do not need explanation. The purpose of the model is to show how the exogenous variables affect and determine the endogenous variables.

With the various existing models, macroeconomists analyse all the variables of interest from the savings rate and its impact on long-term growth to the impact of the minimum wage on unemployment. It is important to mention that not only one model explains all or most of the variables, but it is also a set of models from which conclusions can be drawn for fiscal or monetary policies or other types of policies that are implemented in the economy. To know how good a model is, we must analyse how realistic the assumptions and their exogenous variables are, because if they are far from reality, then the conclusions reached will be erroneous.

Another important branch of the economy is microeconomics which studies how households and companies make decisions and how these decisions affect the market which is the place of interaction between agents. A principle of microeconomics is to assume that companies and households have budget constraints, but always try to maximise their benefit.

Given this analysis of companies and people, microeconomics and macroeconomics are related, since microeconomics starts with the most specific aspects of households and their relationship with companies, and macroeconomics is more general, studying not only this relationship but also studying other components that may affect this relationship and factors beyond these two agents such as international trade, the interest rate, public spending of the government, the rate of investment in an economy, etc. The following graph summarizes the difference between macroeconomics and microeconomics.

macroeconomics and microeconomics

Graph 40. Microeconomics and Macroeconomics. Retrieved 10th December 2017. From https://byjus.com/commerce/microeconomics-and-macroeconomics-study-material/

After decades and decades of studies and new models, there are some lessons that macroeconomists have learned about how the economy works and what its limitations are. One of the most important facts that have been learned is that in the long term the capacity of a country to produce more goods and services will determine the quality of life of its inhabitants. To measure this productive capacity, we have the indicator of real gross domestic product (GDP), which does not consider equality metrics in the distribution of that production, but it serves as an approximation of the quality of life.

It has been established that in countries with higher GDP per capita, the population have higher purchasing power, better social indicators, better health system and even better media coverage.

In the long term, the gross domestic product depends on factors of production such as physical capital, human capital, the technological level of the country and the work required to produce goods and services. Domestic production increases when these factors improve or increase. For example, if more technology is used in production, it will be more efficient, it will require fewer working hours and capital, and therefore companies will be able to produce more. Or when a government encourages and gives access to better education for its population, workers will be capable of performing duties that were previously not capable.

As already mentioned in the previous paragraph, there are several policies a government could adopt to increase the production of goods and services. One of them could be incentives to increase the savings rate,  which serve as an investment source in the future, higher efficiency in production, improve existing standards and institutions that allow the market to have no frictions or information asymmetries among others. That is, there are many ways in which the government can intervene in the trend in which the economy has, but it must act based on studies to know what could be the possible effects of the intervention.

Another important lesson is that in the short-term aggregate demand directly influences the number of goods and services produced within a country. That is a result of the behaviour of prices since in the short term they are almost fixed and do not vary much. Therefore, the factors that affect aggregate demand in the short term will end up affecting domestic production. Fiscal and monetary policies and possible shocks to the goods and services market are directly responsible for the behaviour of the economy in the short term, thus determining production and the unemployment rate.

The third important lesson that macroeconomists have learned is that in the long term the rate of growth of money determines the rate of inflation, but has no influence on real variables such as the growth of production or the rate of employment. When a central bank prints more money, in the long term it will not encourage production or employment, it will only cause a devaluation of the currency due to higher inflation rates. In addition, these higher inflation rates will cause increases in the nominal interest rate. But the fact is that being a nominal variable, the growth of money will not affect real variables in the long term such as employment because the variables that determine that is the rate of layoffs and hiring.

The last significant lesson is that, in the short term, those in charge of monetary and fiscal policies face a tradeoff between inflation and unemployment. Although inflation and unemployment are not related in the long term, in the short term they are. Therefore, often authorities must choose which variable to manage. In the short term, the authorities can use fiscal and monetary policies to expand aggregate demand, which will reduce unemployment, but increase the rate of inflation or in an opposite case, they can use contractionary policies in demand which will control inflation, but will affect jobs. In the long term, they stop being correlated because the expectations of the agents are involved.

Now we will show the factors that macroeconomists have not been able to solve. One of the biggest criticisms to macroeconomics is that alternative theories are not considered, that the whole theory is based on neoclassical models, with assumptions about certain behaviours of the agents and the market that other theories debate.  So the possible errors that the models may produce are widespread because there is no debate on the theoretical principles.

The classical theory assumes a natural rate of unemployment and a potential rate of production. But some economists suggest that these levels are not fixed, they change over time depending on the institutions established and the policies implemented by governments, so it is a mistake to talk about these key levels of the economy.

Another important problem is that many times in those models, which are based on historical facts, they attain results not applicable at present. That is, the growth of countries in the past can be explained, but when lagging countries try to implement the policies that allowed that growth, they cannot achieve the same results. But this is not only a criticism of macroeconomics. It is a crisis in general on economic studies because they manage to explain why the crises happened, but fail to prevent them.

Another problem of macroeconomics is that some economists suggest that it is better not to intervene in the economy due to the lack of precision of the models, and therefore, it is not entirely known whether a policy will have the desired effects on the variables analysed. Also, authorities might pursue political goals such as obtaining popularity or votes, so they would use models and studies that favour them, that might not always be the best for the population.

A neoclassical theory emerged in the late 60s and 70s due to several years of economic weakness and with several recessions in between. The main authorities of countries such as the United Kingdom and the United States tried to encourage the accumulation of physical capital over labour as the predominant factor in retaking corporate and economic profit rates. With these reforms aimed at higher profit margins of companies, the world economy seemed to enter a new stage of bonanza, for which they began to reject alternative theories and its predecessor, the Keynesian theory seemed obsolete.

But the volatility experienced in the last two decades, and mainly the 2007 crisis, is the evidence that the theory aims to understand the economic crises, but fails to prevent highly significant events such as that one that started 10 years ago:  A huge financial breakdown from which many countries have struggled to recover, and the well-being achieved in decades disappeared in a matter of years. This lack of foresight about that episode is evidence of the lack of communication of the neoclassical theory with other theories that perhaps might contribute to the appearance of new concepts that might lead to a better general welfare.

In conclusion, macroeconomics is a branch of the economy that studies the big variables such as unemployment, production, investment and savings among others. It has provided many concepts, and clarity about how the general behaviour of the economy is, and how its different components are related. But being dominated by a mainstream theoretical background that does not admit debates about its principles is a science with limitations.  Macroeconomics still does not achieve its purpose of avoiding major crises, and countries who apply policies based on macroeconomic theory do not develop at the same rates as the reference country. Despite its limitations, it is a valuable tool that allows for better overall well-being than decades prior to the world wars.

 ©Forex.Economy
Categories
Forex Educational Library

Money and Monetary Policy

Introduction

Coming from the Latin word that defined the Roman coin denarius. Money is, in general terms, the preferred means for the exchange (charge vs. payment) of goods and services, likewise cancellation and/or acquisition of rights or obligations.

It can be associated with other functionalities or uses:

MONEY AS A MEDIUM OF EXCHANGE.

Money facilitates any exchange of goods and services among economic agents and reduces transaction costs. Any economic system with a high degree of specialization and division of labor uses money as a medium of exchange or payment of goods produced and services provided by different individuals or persons.

An economic system that excludes money as a medium of exchange of these transactions, involves the application of mediation type barter, time banks

The following properties are required to achieve the present functionality:

  • Homogeneity: The units must be identical or close.
  • Divisibility in units small enough to be able to exchange any good.

 

MONEY AS A STORE OF VALUE.

To be able to recognize it as such, money must satisfy the characteristics of durability, allowing people to keep or accumulate wealth through savings.

Money brings the advantage of its liquidity, understanding this in its broadest possible terms, i.e., the temporary capacity that offers any good to be converted to money, without losing its value in commercial terms over time.

Time can affect the value of money in terms of purchasing power and its relation with market prices in its three temporalities: past, present, and future.

 

MONEY AS A UNIT OF ACCOUNT.

Environment-related to the setting of market prices of goods and services, as well as the control of accounts (accounting).

The monetary unit defines how to measure the expression of the value or market price. Each economic zone shall define its official monetary unit ; $; £

MONEY CLASSIFICATION:

There are several kinds of money varying in liability and strength. When there was ample availability of metals, metal money came into existence later it was substituted by the paper money. According to the needs and availability of means, the kinds of money has changed.

COMMODITY MONEY

Commodity money is generally accepted as means of payment or exchange and is purchased or sold as an ordinary asset. Gold and silver have been the most common precious metals used as money. The value of this kind of money comes from the value of the resource used. It is only limited by the scarcity of the resource.

Some features: Durability; divisibility; transportable; homogeneity; limited offer…

Ex: gold coins, bread, metal, stones, tea, camels…

 

FIAT MONEY

A term used to denote a specific form of currency, not bound to any metal supporting it. A significant amount of the paper currency available all over the world is fiat money.  Fiat money is backed by national governments as the recognized official medium of payment. Fiat money does not hold any inherent worth of its own, and they do not have the support from any form of reserve, as well. It is operating solely on faith, like the sterling used in Scotland. Nowadays, Fiat money is the basis of all the modern monetary systems. The real value of fiat money is determined by the market forces using demand and supply.

The fiat currency is also sanctioned by the Government for payments of taxes or other legal, financial obligations.

 

FIDUCIARY MONEY

Is conventionally maintained on a trust. The fiduciary normally retains the assets for a certain beneficiary, who could even be an executor of a will. Payments of fiduciary money could also be made in commodity money like gold or fiat money. Bank Notes and Checking Accounts are examples of the conventional forms of fiduciary money which, in this case, are provided by Banks.

Fiduciary money can be obtained from banks in the form of credible promises. These promises are eligible to be transferred and do perform the functions of conventional money.

The present-day world attaches higher importance to the token money whose variations are fiduciary money and fiat money, which differ significantly from commodity money.

Ex: Bank Notes, checking accounts…

 

COMMERCIAL BANK MONEY:

It´s possible to describe a commercial bank like an entity that essentially deals with loans and deposits from major business organizations and corporations. Are the most important components of the whole banking system.

The Central Banks and its functions

A Central Bank is a public entity, autonomous and independent of the Government, responsible for the monetary policy of a country.

There´re seven examples of important Central Banks around the world:

Among its functions we can highlight:

  • Establishing the purposes and instruments of monetary policy and implementing.
  • Setting the official interest rate.
  • Centralizing and controlling economic operations abroad, especially making the purchase and sale of foreign currencies that are necessary Managing the country´s Foreign Exchange and gold reserves.
  • Supervising the financial system to ensure its proper functioning and that there are no problems that may affect the economy as a whole.
  • Authorizing the issuance of bills and coins in exclusivity à Controlling the nation’s entire money supply.
  • Acting as a bank of commercial Banks and Government bank.

Since it is responsible for Price stability, Central Banks must regulate the level of inflation controlling the money supply, through the use of monetary policy. A Central Bank performs open market transactions that either inject liquidity into the market or absorb extra funds, directly affecting the level of inflation.

Money Creation

The majority of money in the modern economy is created by commercial banks when making loans.

Money creation in practice differs from some popular misconceptions — banks do not act solely as intermediaries, lending out deposits that savers place with them, and they do not ‘multiply up’ central bank money to create new loans and deposits, either.

The amount of money created in the economy ultimately depends on the monetary policy of the central bank. In normal times, this is carried out by setting interest rates. The central bank can also affect the amount of money directly through purchasing assets or ‘Quantitative Easing.’

Quantitative Easing (QE) is an unconventional form of monetary policy where a Central Bank creates new money electronically to buy financial assets, like government bonds. This process aims to directly increase private sector spending in the economy and return inflation to target.

The aim of quantitative easing is to encourage spending, keeping inflation on track to meet the Government’s inflation target.

QE works, i.e., when we buy gilts, it pushes up their price and so reduces the yield (the return) that investors make when they buy gilts. This encourages investors to buy other assets with higher yields instead, such as corporate bonds and shares. As more of these assets are bought, their prices rise, pushing down borrowing costs for businesses, encouraging them to spend and invest more. We also buy a smaller amount of corporate bonds, which makes it easier for companies to raise money which they can then invest in their business.

Money creation processes by the aggregate banking sector making additional loans

 

 

Limits to broad money creation

  • Banks themselves face limits on how much they can lend. 3 Constraints:
  1. Market forces constrain lending because individual banks have to be able to lend profitably in a competitive market.
  2. Lending is also constrained because banks have to take steps to mitigate the risks associated with making additional loans.
  3. Regulatory policy acts as a constraint on banks’ activities to mitigate a build-up of risks that could pose a threat to the stability of the financial system.
  • Money creation is also constrained by the behavior of the money holders: households and businesses. Households and companies who receive the newly created money might respond by undertaking transactions that immediately destroy it, for example by repaying outstanding loans.
  • The ultimate constraint on money creation is monetary policy. By influencing the level of interest rates in the economy, the monetary policy affects how much households and companies want to borrow.

That occurs both directly, through influencing the loan rates charged by banks, but also indirectly through the overall effect of monetary policy on economic activity in the economy. As a result, the Central Bank is able to ensure that money growth is consistent with its objective of low and stable inflation.

 Money Offer

The total amount of existing money, also called money supply, in an economy consists of cash in the hands of the public and the deposits held in the banks.

That amount of money grows or decreases as a result of bank credit and preference for the public’s liquidity, which together determine the value of the monetary multiplier.

The money supply, M, is, therefore, the result of the expansion of the base money, M0, due to the effect of the monetary multiplier m:

In the money multiplier process, the key is in a very important proportion: the ratio between the reserves of the banks (they correspond to their deposits in the central bank) and the deposits of the public in the banks plus other liabilities.

Banks want to keep that ratio at a certain level, partly to have liquidity with which to deal with withdrawals of funds from their customers and operations with other banks, but, above all, because their central bank, usually, requires them to maintain this relationship above a minimum level.

Depending on the central bank they have different names:

  • ECB → Mandatory minimum reserves
  • FED → Required or mandatory reserves

Therefore, banks keep a slightly higher proportion than the mandatory minimum, so as not to run the risk of breaking that coefficient. Although,  they are not interested in keeping a liquidity level too high because it would mean a loss of return that’s obtainable if they’re able to spend that excess liquidity to buy profitable assets.

Then, when the volume of reserves of banks increases above the mandatory minimum ratio, bank entities may grant credit to the private sector and the public sector. The opposite occurs when their volume of reserves is decreased.

 

An example to clarify this issue:

Let’s assume that the proportion desired by the Central Bank in a certain country is 2%; that is, for every 100 monetary units in deposits, banks need to hold two units in liquid assets.

Imagine that yesterday all banks fulfilled that proportion, and, today, the volume of liquid assets on a certain bank has increased by 100 monetary units. Now, its coefficient is higher than the 2% desired, therefore, the bank will be interested in placing all or part of that surplus, awarding, for example, a credit to the private sector.

How will the maximum amount be known? If the numerator has increased by 100 monetary units and the quotient has to remain 2%, the denominator is allowed an expansion of up to 5,000 monetary units. The process of creating money and the process of creating credit have been launched, the final result of which is a high multiple of the initial operation.

We should understand that the amount of money in circulation varies at every moment, due to the thousands of simultaneous operations of creation, and destruction. It is interesting to realize that Central Banks control this creation process, and for this purpose, it needs a mechanism to increase or reduce the reserve account of the banks and a mechanism to regulate the creation of credit when the reserves grow, as previously commented. It is here when the so-called Monetary Policy is applied.

Each central bank has its own objectives. As is the case of the ECB, whose sole objective is price stability through a low and steady inflation rate of less than or equal to 2% per annum. On the contrary, the FED pursues two objectives: price stability without a quantified inflation level, and maximizing employment, together with the sustainability of long-term interest rates.

The implementation of the monetary policy requires the use of one or several instruments for the creation and destruction of reserves, thus, establishing the initiation of a process of creation or destruction of credit and money.

Although they manage a wide set of tools, they can be summarized into three:

  1. A mechanism for withdrawing and conferring credit from and to the banks. This is the case of the periodic liquidity auctions by the European Central Bank.
  2. Open market operations: buying or selling public debt to banks. When a central bank purchases government bonds from banks, it injects liquidity into the system, and the opposite happens when the central bank sells public doubt to the banks. This is one of the main tools currently used by the FED. Remember the explanation of QE.
  3. And last but not least is the required minimum reserve ratio, where its decrease releases liquidity in banks and increases the amount of money. The opposite holds when there is an increase in the coefficient. It is important to take into account the limited widespread use of this tool. That’s because it usually causes large distortions on the bank’s liquidity.

 

Interest rate

The interest rate is a variable that is present in almost all decisions of households, companies, financial entities and Governments. These decisions refer to actions or consequences that take place at different times of time and therefore, the interest rate represents the price of time. We could interpret it as the prize that is demanded to delay the enjoyment of something from today until tomorrow or the premium that you have to pay to advance that enjoyment from tomorrow to today.

Although there are many types of interest, let’s focus on interest rates of assets and liabilities and financial operations; so we would be dealing with the returns obtained when lending or placing wealth in a financial asset or the cost of Debt.

As already mentioned, central banks usually use two instruments to increase or decrease the circulation of liquid assets or reserves held by banks:

  • The granting of credit to banks →
  • Open market operations →

Central banks usually manage these instruments through a very short-term interest rate. Following the examples of the previous central banks, it is known that the ECB periodically announces an interest rate of the main financing operations that serves as a guide to the banks to the banks for the weekly credit auctions. The extent of that interest rate and its expected future changes will be a useful indicator of the expansive or contractive nature of monetary policy. An increase in that interest rate is indicative of a tightening of monetary policy, that is, a liquidity contraction and a higher cost of central bank credit, as well.

In the FED’s case, this decision sets the federal funds rate, indicating the interest rate at which it is willing to buy public debt to the banks to provide them with liquidity or,  to sell it, thus, withdrawing liquidity. Therefore, that rate and its expected or announced changes will also imply changes in the sign of monetary policy.

However, the central bank controls the short-term interest rate, but families, companies, and Governments are mainly affected by the longer-term rates. This means that monetary policy has a limited, but real, effectiveness on financing conditions.

Therefore, a better understanding of the role of monetary policy in setting interest rates establishes:

  1. In very short terms, interest rates are usually controlled by the rate that the Central Bank uses to implement its monetary policy. If, as an example, we say that the eurozone banks are receiving ECB weekly credits at 2%, a logical assumption will be that the next week’s interest rates will be close to 2%, except if excesses or significant liquidity deficiencies
  2. manifest the Monetary authorities can also influence the longer-term rates, announcing their purposes about future interest rates. That would be the case, for example, when they announce they will keep their interest rates very low for one year.
  3. Authorities may also influence long-term nominal rates if they announce a feasible and credible inflation target.

Central Banks, at best, can only control nominal rates, because the expected rate of inflation will depend on the expectations of economic agents.

In a simplified way, the likely evolution of the relationship between short and long-term types in a country is as follows:

If we take as starting base a situation of a balanced performance of the economic activity, with normal market returns and subsequently, the economic activity accelerates, along with inflation expectations, its likely outcome will be a rise of the long-term interest rates.

Under these conditions, it is likely that the central bank decides to practice a restrictive monetary policy, and therefore, a rise in the interest rates in a very short time.

This monetary policy will end up moderating production and prices. As the markets anticipate this result, the long-term rates will fall again and the central bank will be able to reduce the restrictive nature of its monetary policy by returning to equilibrium.

 

 

Inflation shows the upward or downward movements of thousands of prices, which implies the difficulty in identifying the continuous and sustained changes in the set.

However, the accuracy shown is relevant because a price variation may arise from many possible causes. In the same fashion, it happens on the movements and one-time changes in many prices,  and, also, on the seasonal changes. But beware: a continued and sustained rise in the overall level of prices will not happen without any visible cause.

Who is worried about inflation?

  • Governments
  • companies
  • workers
  • customers

Why?

  • A rise in domestic prices not compensated by the depreciation of the currency produces a loss of competitiveness with other nations.
  • Price raises may alter the distribution of income and wealth, damaging agents who have not been able to anticipate or protect against that. It is for this reason that countries suffering from high and variable inflation also experience episodes of malaise and social conflicts.
  • Inflation can extend over time, generating expectations that often auto-fulfill.
  • It is a non-democratic and regressive tax on money.
  • If inflation is large and variable, it may generate large inefficiencies.
  • Stopping inflation, once installed, is usually difficult and costly.

What is the cause of inflation?

If we take supply and demand as our base assumption, many possible causes can be identified, some on the demand side, such as the increase in consumer income and others on the supply side, such as an increase in the productive factors or the tax levied on the product.

Please note that a significant rise in prices will reduce the purchasing power of money,  which leads to a monetary concentration.  That will, in turn, raise interest rates and slow down the growth of production and prices. However, this will not happen if the growth of money supply is accelerated, which reduces the real interest rates, and, consequently, founds the increase in aggregate demand (consumption, investment, public expenditure, exports, and imports).

Faced with this reality, the following we may state the following:

  • If inflation is not accompanied by growth in money supply, a larger growth on some of the components of aggregate demand or costs (labor, raw materials) will generate a one-time price increase.
  • The creation of an adequate money supply is a necessary condition for any sustained growth of the general price level.

In addition, it can also be a sufficient condition for inflation since if economic agents receive more money than they need to finance their transactions, they will spend it, and in that process, they will generate an increase in the demand for goods and services and a rise in prices.

  • Not all changes in money supply cause a rise in prices: Companies whose sales grow will need a larger balance of money in their possession, money the company won’t expend so that it won’t produce price increases.
  • Therefore, the following approach arises:

Inflation is always a monetary event caused by the excessive growth of the amount of money concerning what is necessary to finance the real growth of the economy. That explains why Central Banks are committed to controlling inflation: because they control the amount of money.

To understand the relationship between Central Banks and inflation, it should be conceded that usually, the monetary authority of a country establishes the objective of its monetary policy in terms of the desired inflation rate (*). This rate of inflation that is usually low, stable and positive, will be the one that the monetary authority tries to achieve in a relatively long term and in this way avoid an erratic monetary policy. Sometimes they include a goal regarding the rate of growth of the gross domestic product, trying to match the potential growth rate of the economy (y*), compatible with a complete use of resources, so that below (left) it, costs tend to be reduced by the pressure of unemployment and above (right), costs tend to increase due to over-use of resources. Therefore, observing the following table, it is understood that point A is the one desired by the monetary authority, as previously mentioned.

If the economy is at point E, the Central Bank will practice an expansive monetary policy and keep interest rates low. When approaching B, it will probably raise the interest rate, with the objective of preventing the economy from moving to the right of y* (before arriving at A) given the slowness of the effects of monetary policy.

In C the monetary policy of the Central Bank will be clearly restrictive, in an attempt to return to A.

In D, the Central Bank will be faced with several alternatives: If it pursues the objective of inflation the action will raise interest rates with the consequent accentuation of the recession. Establishing here an observation beacon for monitoring the reaction of economic agentsI.e. The fear that trade unions might push for higher wages increases the likelihood of an interest rate increase. This explains the reason for the reaction of the Central Banks to the rise in costs such as oil or ad valorem taxes even if they produce one-time price increases  → The fear that that may turn into wage increases, even more so if they use automatic indexing on wages.

An inflation like C is attacked by the use of a restrictive monetary policy, and a reduction of the rate of growth in production is the first parameter to be affected, which will shift to F, and solely after a while, it will end up achieving the objective: A.

Inflation is maintained around the desired level * through an expansive monetary policy but at a very moderate level, and it must be accompanied by other measures such as:

  • The prohibition for the central bank to finance the public deficit, thus avoiding the excessive growth of the amount of money.
  • A monetary exchange rate policy compatible with the monetary restriction
  • Salary moderation as a countermeasure, to avoid more rigorous monetary restrictions and its negative effects such as unemployment and recession before inflation can be reduced.
  • Credibility and perseverance in government policy, because if Government’s announcements lack these attributes in the eyes of the economic agents, the moderation of inflation will be a lot more difficult.

 

Value: To be able to add the production of heterogeneous goods and services and express them in a common monetary unit: Pound Sterling, Dollar, Euro.

Final: To avoid the problem of the double accounting of goods that become part of the production of other goods and services, such as raw materials and intermediate products. GDP equals added value.

Of Production: Not of sales.

Of goods and services: But only the remunerated ones, so leisure, study, bricolage… and the legal ones are excluded.  Underground economy and the illegal activities are not included: drug trafficking …

In a country: Region or city. It will depend on what you want to cover.

During a given period: (one quarter, one year …). Transactions carried out with goods produced in the past are not included.

At market prices: (sale to the public) including net indirect taxes (VAT).

To understand GDP, it is necessary to know other concepts related to:

There are three procedures to calculate the GDP of a country:

 

 

 

 

Kind regards

 

©Forex.Academy 

Categories
Forex Educational Library

Short-Term Economics

Abstract

It is true that the long-term is more important than the short term in the economy, but there are variables that it is important to analyze in the short term such as the internal consumption of people, investment, the trade balance, the exchange rate, and others. When people are analyzing the short term, it can be concluded why an economy is behaving in a certain way since variables that are constantly changing are analyzed. Even fiscal and monetary policies are based more on the short term because they have to correct the failures that exist in economic cycles so that the crises are not so deep and that the booms do not turn out to be negative, as in some cases it has been presented euphoria in the stock market.

In an economy there are different agents such as companies, consumers or the state and each of them makes their decisions in different ways. Therefore, if someone wants to understand how the demand for goods behaves it is necessary to decompose the aggregate production (gross domestic product) from the point of view of the different goods produced and the different buyers. When GDP is decomposed several important components can be seen.

The first component of the gross domestic product is consumption. It represents the goods and services purchased by consumers ranging from food to luxury goods. In all countries, this is the most predominant component of the gross domestic product. The second component is the investment which considers the investment in capital and the residential investment. The third component is public expenditure which represents the goods and services purchased by the state, but this component does not consider the transfers made by the state nor the interest paid by the public debt. In the chart below, you can see the spending of three countries as a percentage of the gross domestic product.

Expense

Graph 11. Expense. Data taken from the World Bank

To find the purchase of domestic goods and services should be subtracted imports and added exports. The subtraction between exports and imports is called the trade balance. If exports are higher than imports, it is said that the country has a trade surplus. If exports are lower than imports, the country is said to have a trade deficit. With what has been mentioned so far, we have analyzed some sources of purchases or sales of goods and services. To analyze the production, it must be considered that companies may have inventories from previous years or that they do not sell all their products in the current year. The difference between goods produced and goods sold in a year is called inventory investment. This investment is usually small and can be positive or negative. The following two graphs show exports and imports respectively from four countries.

Exports of goods and services

Graph 12. Exports of goods and services. Data taken from the World Bank

 

Imports of goods and services

Graph 13. Imports of goods and services Data taken from the World Bank

 

Consumption decisions depend on many factors, but the main one is available disposable income after paying taxes and other compulsory expenses. It is normal that, if disposable income increases over a long period of time, the demand for goods increases. The effect of income on consumption is called the marginal propensity to consume and this effect may be different between countries. In conclusion, consumption depends on income and taxes.

As for public expenditure is determined by the fiscal policy of each state. It is directly affected by taxes since these are the main source of income for a state. As states do not behave as companies or consumers cannot establish rules about this component since it involves policy, so it is not easy to analyze how the fiscal policy of countries

The production depends on the demand which depends on the rent. So, an increase in public spending causes an increase in production and this leads to an increase in income-generating an impact on demand and this again affects production and so on. Given the above, it is important to analyze what effects each component of GDP has since all variables are related to each other. But despite the models that indicate how each variable affects production is impossible for governments to reach the level of production they want because there will always be external shocks, or the expectations of agents will not respond as expected.

In the next part of the article, we analyze the determinants of the demand for money. In the economy, there are several types of instruments such as bonds, shares and bank deposits. Also, people could decide to have all their wealth of money which would be more comfortable since they would not have to make transactions nor go to the bank, but that also means that they will not receive any interest in this so the decision to have cash or does not depend on the yields of the various instruments. The determinants of the demand for money will be our number of transactions and the interest rate. The interest rate serves to intervene in the economy by the central bank affecting consumer decisions.

The demand for money from the economy is no more than the sum of everyone’s money demands. For everyone, the demand for money increases in proportion as income increases and the demand for money has an inverse relationship with the interest rate. The higher the interest rate set by the central bank the higher the opportunity cost of having money in the pocket and the better it would be to have bonds or deposits in the bank.

The money supply will now be analyzed. In economies, there are two sources of supply. The first, bank deposits that are offered to the public and the second source is the cash offered by the central bank. When there is an increase in the national income this leads to the demand for money increases, but not the supply, which generates an increase in the interest rate to balance supply and demand. So, when the central bank increases the money supply generates a decrease in the interest rate to reach equilibrium in the money market by increasing the demand for money. It is important to keep in mind that these interest rates that are modified are in the short term.

In current economies, central banks change the money supply by buying or selling bonds in open market operations. If a central bank wants more liquidity in the economy, it buys bonds and pays them by creating money and if it wants to remove liquidity it sells bonds to collect money from the economy. With these open market operations, the economies succeeded in modifying the short-term interest rate. This short-term, as well as long-term rate, affects the investment of the economy as consumers and companies take these rates into account in their decisions. The higher the interest rate both short and long term will be more expensive for the company to borrow and will postpone this decision. In the equilibrium of the goods market, a rise in the interest rate will cause a decrease in production.

In current economies, governments and central banks combine fiscal and monetary policies to have deeper effects on the economy and take it along the path they believe is right, but they do not always agree on their policies. When there are recessions in the countries is when the banks and governments agree to get the economy out of this state. At other times when the bank takes an expansive monetary policy the government may have a contractive fiscal policy this depends on the expectations of each and what the objective of each agent.

After the implementation of these policies the adjustment in the economy is not immediately and each agent takes time to adjust their decisions, so when taxes rise consumption takes time to show the effects or the same when the monetary policy is changing when the central bank lowers its interest rates consumption does not respond immediately because the economy has transmission channels that are not updated in a quick way. In addition, in each country, the transmission time of the policies can vary because each consumer or company in each country acts differently so it cannot take an estimated transmission time globally.

Now we will discuss the trade balance issue. Nowadays the world is totally globalized and so is the economy. Globalization brought with it greater competition for local companies and specialization of economies, taking advantage of their competitive advantages thanks to their geographical location or climate. Exports represent important percentages in the domestic production of a country. Imports are also positive if consumer welfare is analyzed as they will have more variety of products and will be able to choose better goods. This decision of consumers and companies sometimes buying foreign and non-local goods obviously affect local production.

In the decision to buy inland or foreign goods is fundamental the price of goods in the choice of which to buy. The comparison of foreign and local prices is a relative price and is called the real exchange rate. This rate is the important one to know because the agents prefer local or foreign goods as it indicates the relative terms of exchange, but in goods not in currency. The real exchange rate is an index number i.e. it does not transmit direct information, but it can indicate whether in a country with the passing of time the goods became more expensive or not with respect to other countries what matters is the variation of this exchange rate.

A rise in the real exchange rate means a real appreciation and a reduction in the rate is called real depreciation. But globalization consists not only in the exchange of goods and services but also the opening of financial markets. This opening also affects the trade surplus or deficit of countries. If a country is in a trade deficit, it means that a country is buying more from the rest of the world than it sells to them and therefore must borrow from international agencies to balance its accounts. The investment decision of the financial markets will depend on the differential of the interest rate between countries, the political risk and the growth prospects of the regions among other risks. In the following chart, you can see the net inflow of capital at current prices in dollars.

Foreign direct investment, net inflows

Graph 14. Foreign direct investment, net inflows. Data taken from the World Bank

 

In conclusion, the real rate affects the composition of consumer spending on domestic and foreign goods, although in the first instance it should not affect the total level of consumption. The same can happen with investment, the real exchange rate can influence the decision of companies to buy local or foreign capital, and for the financial markets enter other variables that will decide which is preferred by the investors like the difference of interest rate.

 ©Forex.Analysis
Categories
Forex Education Forex Educational Library

Long run Macroeconomics

Abstract

Long term is what really matters for economists. It is not enough a decade of continuous growth if an economy does not have adequate policies to perpetuate that growth. So, the models in general in macroeconomics are about the long term. As mentioned in other articles, the economy fluctuates permanently along a trend and it is normal to present crisis in certain periods of time. But to ensure production growth constantly over time, government policies must focus on variables such as savings rate, capital accumulation, human capital development among others that offer the ability to maintain stable growth.

In the long term of the economy, the interannual fluctuations of economic activity predominate. When recessions happen, causes consumers to be pessimistic and when the economy is expanding, consumers are optimistic and their behaviors demonstrate. But if you look to the past in long periods of time the panorama changes, and fluctuations are not important but the long-term growth is. What matters, in the long run, is the historical aggregate production, so the objective of this branch of macroeconomics is to determine which factors affect long-term growth, why some countries grow more than others and why there are more inequalities between countries. In the following graph, you can see the growth of some countries.

GDP PER CAPITA

Graph 1 GDP PER CAPITA. Data taken from the World Bank.

The reason why growth is important is that this determines the standard of living and determines whether it has improved this in time. Because of this, what matters to macroeconomics is not only aggregate production but production per person as this approximates each person’s standard of living. Economists do not ignore the fact of inequality, but studies and models try to approach reality so it is necessary to have these variables that even though they are not entirely true, they approximate to reality. At this point, there are several variables that try to measure the quality of life of people as their consumption, necessities unmet, among others, which measure the overall well-being

When you compare production per person you should adjust by purchasing power parity, in other words, the prices are adjusted in real terms to be able to compare a basket of goods that can be bought in each country, otherwise, these indicators would be affected by exchange rates. One of the great conclusions that can be seen after seeing the growth of different countries is that in general welfare in all countries has increased and in some countries, growths have converged at similar rates, but there are others in which the Growth seems to have stagnated as in Africa and some countries in South America

To analyze growth in countries, economists have used long-term models, initiated by Robert Solow at the beginning of 1950. The models consider aggregate production and try to have variables that affect production such as capital and workers in an economy. The way in which these two factors are related to the models is affected by technology, as an economy with a higher technology will be more efficient with the factors it has and thus will reach greater aggregate production. With such simplified models, graphics are very similar to reality, and it is also concluded that growth rates stop increasing in certain periods of time and by the characteristic of declining yields. What indicates declining yields of the factors is that the larger the accumulation of these factors, they cease to be so productive because the economy is saturated with these and are no longer as necessary as in the beginning.

With these concepts clear it is valid to ask yourself the question why an economy grows and which factors promote the growth. With long-term macroeconomic models, it is concluded that increases in worker output are due to increases in capital per worker, technological improvements or more skilled workers. The education is a very interesting explanation because it explains the great growth after the Second World War as technological innovations made production more efficient in all countries and the knowledge of people also had an expansion during this period. In conclusion, what determines long-term production is the relationship between production and capital as the amount of capital determines production. In graph 2, the gross capital formation is a variable of physical capital.

Gross capital formation

Graph 2 Gross capital formation. Data taken from the World Bank

Another important aspect of the long-term growth of economies is the saving rate of each economy. It has been seen in data that the most saving economies grow more in the long run and an example of this are the Asian economies that have high savings rates and thus grow more than the average of countries. Similarly, technological progress helps to grow constantly more than in the past. But here arises another concern, what determines the rate of technological progress? The answer is the projects that are carried out in an economy and the way the economy is organized, its rules and the institutions.

Governments can influence the saving rate in various ways. In the first place, they can change public savings, in other words, to have a surplus in the government budget. Moreover, governments can use taxes to influence private savings, for example, they can grant tax privileges to people who save to make more beneficial the saving. But at this point arises a problem and is that consumption suffers when there are higher rates of savings and the desire of an economy that grows is that people consume more so there should be a limit on savings rates because an economy with excessively high rates is also not ideal for economists. But if you take an economy with zero savings to invest in capital, the economy will have zero capital and consumption will also have the same value, so it is better than the saving rate is positive but not excessive as consumption will also be null and that is not the ideal of the economy. In graph 3, a gross saving rate can be observed in which the most developed countries are the ones with the highest savings rates.

Gross savings

Graph 3 Gross savings. Data taken from the World Bank

There is empirical evidence that most countries are below the optimum savings level and are therefore below their optimal capital level and their consumption is not the maximum they could get. But the savings rates that are considered in these initial models are only used to acquire physical capital, but as mentioned previously, economies have another capital that is also very important which is human capital. An economy that has many skilled workers will be much more productive than another that does not have the same types of workers. Human capital has increased as much as physical capital in the last two centuries. It is known that at the beginning of the first Industrial Revolution, 30% of the workers knew how to read and now that percentage is located at 95%. Graph 4 shows the difference in the rates of children enrolled in tertiary education.

Gross enrolment ratio

Graph 4 Gross enrolment ratio. Data taken from the World Bank

After having introduced the distinction within the capital of an economy it can be concluded that the level of production of an economy depends on physical capital, human capital, and technology present in an economy. An increase in the physical capital per worker and an increase in the average level of qualifications per worker would lead to an increase in production per worker. A problem is that the population today is so educated and the yields of this are also decreasing the most children now know how to read, write and have the possibility of going to college so it is no longer so representative the education as it was in the last century. Savings also influence human capital as an increase in savings in this capital increases production per worker.

Considering another important variable in long-term growth the technological progress will be exposed. Technological progress helps economic growth at least in the short term because it makes the economy more efficient and allows new objects to be produced at higher speeds. But it is not a permanent effect because after the economy is accustomed to these innovations, its effect on growth disappears. Technological progress reduces the number of workers needed to achieve a certain amount of production, in other words, it allows to produce more without having to increase the factors already exposed.

Technological progress has made great strides throughout history from finding sources of energy to the understanding of the human body. In modern economies, most of the technological progress comes from investment in research and development, which is commonly denoted (R&D). According to some estimates, countries allocate between 3% and 5% of GDP and modern companies allocate large resources to this in order to be at the forefront of the market. For a company to have incentives to invest in research and development there must be clear rules such as proprietary rights and patents that guarantee companies to receive returns on investment in R&D. In Figure 5, the difference in research between countries can be seen.

Researchers in R&D

Graph 5 Researchers in R&D. Data taken from the World Bank.

There is data showing that the recorded growth from 1950 to the present has been generated by the technological process rather than the accumulation of physical capital, but without the latter being negligible for economic growth. Throughout history it has been seen that the poorest countries have less physical capital initially but then converge their growth rates with the most developed because they implement the technological progress of the most advanced countries, in other words, they take advantage of the progress of developed countries and as the technological levels converge, the production per worker is also converging. This is one of the central ideas about technological progress, as the most advanced countries are on the technological frontier and must innovate more, while lagging countries can mimic the technology of the advanced countries and close the gap between them without having to innovate. While this occurs in some countries, not all are able to do so due to inefficient policies and institutions.

 

©Forex.Academy

Categories
Forex Educational Library

Limitations On Monetary Policy

 Abstract

Macroeconomics currently has different models to analyze how markets behave, which relationship has different indicators and what effect the application of certain policies could have. But the problem with the theory is that it does not consider all the variables that really affect, and a principle of the models is the simplicity and because there are variables that behave differently than would be expected. This mainly occurs with the expectations of people because it is a variable that cannot be controlled and can behave very differently than would be expected.

In the last century, various models have been developed to explain economic behavior, but it is still far from perfection. When central banks see an increase in unemployment, they try to give a stimulus to the economy with the help of the interest rate or with an increase in the amount of money. But when those incentives are considered, the banks use macroeconomic models to see the possible effects of their measures, although there is no perfect model to indicate the real effects. The problem is that in the diversity of models that exist each one shows different magnitudes in the effects of the interventions so that the banks do not know with certainty what can happen in the economy.

Given this uncertainty about the effects of economic policy, some analysts believe that central banks should not intervene so much in the economy to avoid possible unwanted effects. In general terms, central banks should limit themselves to avoiding prolonged recessions, curbing dangerous expansions, and avoiding inflationary pressures. The higher the unemployment or the inflation the measures of the bank should be stronger but neither aspires to a perfect effect since this does not exist.

One of the main reasons why the effects of monetary policy are uncertain is a topic discussed in the article Expectations in the economy. Expectations and their interaction with central bank policies distort the effects of policies, because not only the variables of the present matter but the expectations of the future as well. For a central bank policy to be efficient and have the desired effects their policies must be credible by the agents of the economy to change the expectations of these.

But another problem facing monetary policy apart from the expectations of consumers, investors and other players, is the political interests of the authorities of the countries. Politicians do not always do the best for the economy as they always avoid making difficult decisions and always do what they are represented by votes. Another problem is the alternation in the power of different ideologies that do not allow economic and monetary policies to be lasting over time. All the above is to highlight the limitations of monetary authorities and because despite the development of economic theory it has not been possible to perfect predictions about the effects of monetary policy.

One of the issues that banks should deal with is inflation. Inflation has four costs recognized by economists:

  • An increase in inflation leads to an increase in the nominal interest rate and therefore the cost of opportunity to have money so that people prefer money in the bank and this leads to having to go more often to the bank.
  • Inflation generates fiscal distortions. For example, when a company must pay capital and income taxes if there is a high inflation rate it may end up paying more because of this effect.
  • Inflation variability generates that year after year no one knows exactly what the inflation rate will be affecting certain assets such as bonds.
  • Inflation causes an effect called monetary illusion that causes people to make systematic mistakes because they value different real and nominal purchasing power changes.

But inflation also has positive aspects. The creation of money by banks and which is the cause of inflation is a way in which the state can finance its spending, for example, it is an alternative to borrowing from the public or raise taxes. It is also positive because when an economy is in a recession the central bank can take expansionary measures and thus help the economy. But if the economy has 0 inflation, or it is very low, monetary policy will be hard to implement and therefore it will be difficult to return production to its natural levels by the bank. In many countries, the main objective of central banks is to achieve an inflation rate between a pre-determined range for each bank that is supposed to be good for the economy. In the following graph, you can see the inflation rate of different countries including Venezuela that is having serious problems in its economy.

Inflation, consumer prices

Graph 9. Inflation, consumer prices. Data taken from the World Bank.

Another way aside from the interest rate to control production fluctuations is the fiscal deficit. It is true that the fiscal deficit helps in the negative cycles, but it must also be considered that fiscal deficits have a negative impact on capital accumulation in the long term. For the debt not to advance continuously when there are expansions in the economy it should be intended to have fiscal surpluses to clean up national accounts. Due to the problems generated by an increase in the debt generated by the fiscal deficit, it is important that investors and citizens are monitoring the fiscal deficit of countries as this can end up affecting the growth in the medium and long-term.

As mentioned before the policy plays an important role in the monetary decisions and the course of the economies so that the healthiest thing for the countries would be to limit their interference in the decisions of the Central Bank and other policies aimed at limiting the fiscal deficits because to not lose support a government may be able to borrow beyond what is necessary and healthy by affecting long-term growth where those governments will no longer be.

European Union.

The next part of the article will be based on the monetary integration of Europe and the details of this integration. The decision to adopt a single currency such as the Euro is the most extreme way to set the exchange rate between countries in a region. When the central bank worries about the exchange rate and tries to fix a stable exchange rate there are many problems for the parity to remain so by unifying several countries under a currency these problems are eliminated as losses of reserves, but other problems arise. In the next graphic shows the members current of the European Union.

Top 30 maps and charts that explain the European Union

Graph 10. Buczkowski A. (2017, March 27). Top 30 maps and charts that explain the European Union. Retrieved October 16, 2017, from http://geoawesomeness.com/top-30-maps-charts-explain-european-union/.

The European countries managed to establish a single currency because throughout history they had had some concerns that led them to take this measure. The first factor is the openness of European economies since they are so exposed to trade, so they are also more exposed to fluctuations in the exchange rate than other countries in the world. The greater proportion of exports or imports in national income the economy is more sensitive to changes in the exchange rate. Secondly, Europe has historically great fluctuations that have led to economic crises and conflicts between them. And the last factor determining the monetary union in Europe was the common agricultural market. This market for its operation needed a stable exchange rate so that helped in the decision to unify the currency.

Then introducing the causes of Europe’s monetary union will now discuss how monetary policy is managed. Europe’s monetary policy is managed by the European Central Bank which, together with the central banks of all the Member States of the European Union, constitutes the European system of central banks. This system is independent of other institutions such as national governments. Monetary policy decisions are centralized in the European Central Bank so that European monetary policy is unique, but its application is decentralized in the national central banks who are responsible for carrying out operations of an open market in their countries.

The governing bodies of the European Central Bank are the Governing Council and the Executive Committee. The Governing Council is composed of the six members of the executive committee and the governors of the national central banks of the countries that are part of the eurozone. This body is responsible for monetary policy and sets out the guidelines for its implementation. The council normally meets twice a month on Thursdays. The executive committee implements monetary policy and gives instructions to the national central banks. The governing bodies of the European Central Bank agree on the policy to be implemented by voting and win the decision that has the most votes. The governors of the national central banks have the same weight in the votes regardless of the economic importance of each country.

The basic task of the European Central Bank is to manage the monetary policy of the European Union and the main priority of this policy is the stability of prices. The bank has established that price stability is defined as an inter-annual increase in euro-zone price indices of less than 2% but positive. Due to this, the central bank decides its corrective measures based on the deviations of the expected inflation with respect to the desired path. To achieve the price target, the central bank has two strategies, the first is related to the money supply and consists of announcing the benchmark for the growth of money. The second strategy consists of an economic analysis of different economic indicators such as economic activity, labor costs, financial assets among others and with this analysis are fixed the interest rates.

A major problem facing the central bank when making decisions is the economic fluctuations of each member country of the European Union. The asymmetric economic cycles have their origin in different specializations of each country and that causes asymmetric perturbations since the most developed sectors in each country face different offers and demands. There is evidence that, with the European Union, many regions have reduced the possibility of being affected by asymmetric shocks thanks to economic integration, but this effect has not been seen in all countries.

An important factor that reduced the costs of monetary union is the existence of interregional labor mobility, since if the demand for a product in one country is reduced and the labor force in another increase the labor force can move freely to the country where it has this more developed sector. But despite good labor mobility, some economists argue that Europe is not an optimal monetary union since country governors vote for measures favorable to their respective countries or otherwise the measures end up affecting more a country that is in a recession than a country that is well economically.

 

©Forex.Academy

Categories
Forex Educational Library

Labor Market and its Implications

Abstract

One of the aspects that matter most to people about economics is the labor market. It is of special interest because much of the population is active in this market, so it is important to analyze how it behaves, which variables are more important to determine wages. In addition, what problems imply some policies that in the first instance try to protect workers, but end up affecting it as it is the minimum wage. Likewise, unions represent certain frictions in the labor market that, consequently, have undesirable negative effects.

 

The labor market in the economy is one of the most important issues in the economy. To analyze how the job market behaves some concepts must be clear

  • Active population: Sum of people who are working or looking for work.
  • Inactive population: People who do not work and do not seek work.
  • Activity Rate: Active population/working-age population. In Europe, as well as most developed countries the rate of activity has increased over time due to the inclusion in women’s labor market, although this fact does not occur in all countries.
  • Unemployment rate: unemployed/active population. The unemployment rate can reflect two different realities. It can reflect an active labor market where there are large numbers of layoffs, but also of hiring. Or it can reflect a stagnant job market where there is little movement. To find out what is behind the aggregate unemployment rate, workers ‘ movements need to be analyzed and this data can be obtained from quarterly surveys conducted in the countries.

The following charts show the rates of participation of men and women respectively in the labor market

Labor market and its implications

Graph 15. Labor force participation rate, male. Data taken from the World Bank

Labor force participation rate female

 

Graph 16. Labor force participation rate, female. Data taken from the World Bank.

It’s important to keep in mind that many times the surveys carried out and the numbers given by the media do not reflect the reality, because in some cases people looking for work stop looking because they do not find and take these people as an inactive population and this reduces the unemployment rate which politicians use to say that the economy has a good performance which is not true. So, to have a complete picture of job creation and destruction and to know if it is true the unemployment rate is better to review workers ‘ movement surveys.

The job market like any other market has a price variable, which is the salary. Salaries are determined in many ways, sometimes they are determined by collective bargaining between companies and workers, but these negotiations do not cover all workers. Some negotiations are bilateral between a businessman and a private worker. Although in each country differs in the way wages are adjusted, a theory can be developed to explain how the salaries are determined.

According to economic theory, workers usually receive a higher salary than their reserve salary which is the minimum level at which workers are indifferent between working or not. That is, most people receive a salary that at least encourages them to work. Moreover, salaries depend on the situation of the labor market. When the unemployment rate decreases the wages increase because there are fewer job offers. Even when there is no collective bargaining between employers and workers, workers have some bargaining power that they can use to get better wages than their reserve wages

Some companies can pay higher salaries than others to encourage their employees or attract more skilled workers. In the negotiations the companies consider the costs of hiring an employee, the costs of firing him and how much it would cost him to maintain these. The more expensive it is for a company to replace its workers, it will be willing to pay more to keep them. But this is not the only reason to pay better salaries some companies want their workers to be more comfortable in their work and have better performance, so they decide to pay salaries that are called efficiency wages.

As previously mentioned the labor market situation also influences wages. When the unemployment rate is low it is harder to find skilled workers, so wages increase. The following charts show the unemployment rate of several countries and the growth of production.

Unemployment rate

Graph 17. Unemployment rate. Data taken from the World Bank

 

Gross Domestic Product

 

Graph 18. Gross Domestic Product. Data taken from the World Bank

Now it will be analyzed some variables that affect the wage negotiation. On the one hand, workers do not care about the level of nominal wages, but they do care about real wages as this indicates how many goods can be bought. On the other hand, companies do not care how much the salary they pay, but they care about the relationship between the salary they pay and the price of the goods they sell. As these variables are those that come into the decisions of the agents, this article must analyze what happens when they change. For example, if the price level increases in a certain proportion, workers will ask for an increase of at least the magnitude of the price increase as their purchasing power is reduced. Companies will be willing to increase maximum wages in the magnitude that increased the prices. But the decision to set wages will depend primarily on the bargaining power of each agent

Given the above, the existence of trade unions are important as they have more bargaining power than people individually. If there are unions, they will ask that the wage increase be at least the magnitude of the inflation. But if companies are the ones with the decision-making power, they will make the decision to raise wages less than inflation, as they earn a higher income by having better sales margins. Likewise, the existence of a minimum wage or unemployment insurance would alter the labor market.

If there is unemployment insurance in an economy, people will have a higher reserve salary because when they are unemployed they will have an income for a certain amount of time, so it will be harder for them to work for a low salary. This gives a little bit of bargaining power to the workers because if they don’t feel motivated by a company they will decide to quit and be unemployed for a while until they find a job that motivates them enough. Efficiency wages will also have to be higher because it is not so expensive to be unemployed for people.

Another variable affecting wage fixing is the existence of a minimum wage or protection of workers as it may be in some cases that the minimum wage is higher than the reserve salary of the people so that it will be positive for the workers but for companies will be a contracting barrier and in some cases it can increase the unemployment rate in the countries because if the minimum wage level is above the productivity of the workers and is greater than their reserve salary will be very expensive for companies to hire and decide to hire less or use machines that lower their production.

Now it will analyze the aggregate supply of goods and their relationship with the labor market. An increase in production causes an increase in employment. The increase in employment causes a decrease in unemployment and therefore in the unemployment rate, which causes nominal wages to rise as well since it is more difficult for companies to replace their workers. The rise in nominal wages causes prices to rise on the part of companies. These effects also affect the agent’s expectations if prices are expected to increase in a certain proportion in the future in the negotiations, the salary will be asked to increase in the same way.

In the demand when there is an increase in the price level this causes a reduction in production as it decreases the real quantity of the amount of money which leads to an increase in the interest rate which in turn leads to a decrease in the demand for goods and services. Production depends negatively on taxes and positively on the real amount of money in the economy and on public spending.

In some situations, in the short term, production is higher than the natural level of the economy, that is, the economy is producing beyond its capabilities. When this happens, the price level increases which leads to higher expected inflation and this ends up impacting wage negotiations. The above effect concludes with a decrease in the real amount of money which generates an increase in the nominal interest rate and this reduces the levels of production taking it to its natural level. It is normal that in the short term the growth of production is above or below the natural level, but in the long term, these imbalances are eliminated.

After analyzing the aggregate demand, the short and medium-term effects of an expansionary monetary policy will be analyzed. In principle, when a central bank emits more money to the economy, the amount of real money increases and therefore production does so in the short term. This leads to an increase in the price level which affects the price expectations. The effect of monetary expansion dissipates when production returns to its natural level thanks to the fact that price expectations adjust to this new scenario leading to higher wages in the short term.

On the other hand, inflation also affects the supply and aggregate demand for goods. An increase in expected inflation causes an increase in effective inflation since there are several channels of transmission of these expectations. A channel is the negotiation of contracts because if they expect a higher price level in the future they will set higher nominal wages, which in effect leads to higher prices in the future. Inflation is also related to unemployment since when there is an increase in the unemployment rate this causes a decrease in inflation. This occurs because an increase in unemployment causes a reduction in nominal wages, which directly leads to a reduction in the price level.

In conclusion, the labor market is very important for people because they are constantly involved in it. In some countries, there are rigidities in this market that end up affecting the whole economy as we saw in this article because it ends up affecting inflation and production. Unemployment insurance, a high degree of employee protection, forms of wage negotiations and the minimum wage are some of the rigidities that the labor market faces. When the inflation rate reaches a high level, inflation tends to be more variable and consequently, the agents of the economy are more reluctant to sign long-term contracts that are not flexible. That is why salary negotiations are done every year or even for shorter periods of time.

In the medium term, the growth of production is equal to the normal rate of growth, unemployment is equal to its natural rate and both variables are independent of the growth of the nominal amount of money. The growth of the nominal amount of money only affects inflation. That is, inflation is always a purely monetary phenomenon since, in the presence of other factors such as monopolies, unions, and strikes, fiscal deficits do not affect inflation unless they affect the nominal amount of money.

 

©Forex.Academy

Categories
Forex Educational Library

Expectations about the Economy

Abstract

There are a great many intertwining variables that influence the current state of the economy at any given time; such as unemployment, wages, internal production, investments and many more. But with all of them, it is the expectations of people, and investors that generate certain effects, that explain the behavior of some of these variables and which will affect future conditions. For example, if people expect future interest rates to be higher, they will consume or ask for more loans in the present because in the future it will be more expensive to consume. But without rising interest rates, consumption varies today due to expectations. Another example is the expected interest rates in a country, depending on these expectations the investors decided where to place their capital without waiting for this to happen.

The economy in its short-and long-term models must consider the expectations of consumers, companies and all representative agents within an economy. To consider the subject of expectations first the interest rate variable must be introduced. Interest rates expressed in units of a national currency are referred to as nominal interest rates and these rates appear in newspapers and financial pages. Interest rates expressed in a basket of goods are called the real interest rate and are called that because it is beyond inflation and reflects the cost of acquiring goods that will be consumed by people, what is truly important.

There is an equation that establishes that the real interest rate equals (approximately) the nominal interest rate minus the expected inflation. That is why in some media, although they mention a decrease of the interest rates it is said that the interest rate is still contractionary or it may be that the nominal is lower one year than another, but that does not indicate that loans are cheaper than the previous year, so you should consider real interest rates. The interest rate directly affected by the monetary policy is the nominal interest rate. The interest rate that affects spending and production is the real interest rate. Given this difference, it will be possible to see in the news that they contradict the potential effects of monetary policy on the economy and financial markets. In the following graph, you can see the real interest rate of some countries.

Graph 6 Real Interest Rate. Data taken from the World Bank.

To summarize the issue of interest rates it should be clarified that the nominal interest rate indicates how many euros must be returned in the future to obtain a euro today and the real interest rate tells us how many goods must be returned in the future to obtain a good today. Nominal interest rates will affect investment decisions between bonds, stocks, and money, while the real interest rate will affect project investment decisions. In the short term, an increase in the growth of money leads to a decrease in both nominal interest rates and the real rate, in the medium term, an increase in the growth of money will not affect the real interest rate, but if it raises the nominal interest rate.

The bonds issued by a country are differentiated in two aspects: their risk of default and the time of their pay. There are some bonds that have better coupons than others, which are riskier by defaults and that ends up affecting the price of bonuses. But for economic purposes, this part of the article will focus on the bond term. Bonds with different times of paid have different prices and different interest rates that will be called yields. The yields of short-term bonds, usually a year or less, are termed short-term yields and, if the bonds are more than one year, they are called long-term yields.

The interesting thing about analyzing the bonds is to determine the curve of the yields and the relationship between short-term and long-term rates. The price of a one-year bond varies inversely with the nominal interest rate at one year that is in effect at the present. The price of a two-year bond depends both on the interest rate to a current year at the present, as well as the expected interest rate for the following year. The interesting thing about analyzing bond prices is that bond yields contain the same information about future interest rates as the bond yield curve fully reflects the agents ‘ expectations of the economy of a Country.

To begin the analysis, a term performance must be defined; The term yield of a bond to N years, or in other words the N years interest rate is the constant annual rate that makes the current price of the bond equal to the current value of the future interests generated by this. By examining the yields of the bonds at different times, we can deduce the expectations of the financial markets on future short-term interest rates. For example, if you want to see the expectations of the financial markets in one year you should observe two-year bonds which have included expectations about the interest rate that will be at the end of the year and observe bonds to a year of maturation.

When the yield curve has a positive slope is when long-term interest rates are higher than the short-term, financial markets expect short-term interest rates to increase in the future. When the yield curve has a negative slope long-term interest rates are lower than those of the short-term, but markets expect this situation to change and short-term interest rates fall in the future. To observe market expectations during the crises of 2000, 2007 and others, it is interesting to observe the curves of the bonds of the countries that reflect the expectations of the financial markets and the decisions that were expected to be taken by the banks Central. It is important to note that the interpretation of performance curves only focuses on expectations and in most cases the decisions of banks and market agents are unpredictable. In the following two graphs you can see the bonus yield curve. In the first graph, you can see a bond of Colombia and in the second is the types of curves of yields.

Graph 7.   Curva de Rentabilidad TES Tasa Fija 

Graph 8. Roca E.  Estrategias con bonos

Leaving the issue of bonds aside, the behavior and expectations of consumers and businesses will now be analyzed. These two market agents always respond to their expectations about the future. In economic models, you have a consumer who is extremely far-sighted about the future so consumers will always be thinking about what affects their consumption in the following periods. While not all consumers are like that, in reality, it is a simplification that helps to understand the formation of expectations and how they would respond to an external shock.

To understand consumption decisions, it is essential to take an intertemporal perspective because what a consumer spends and borrows today will impact their future consumption. It is assumed that individuals are rational but in the models, it is assumed that the individuals are identical to simplify the models. According to the theoretical models, consumers are very sensitive to variations in income. An explanation of this is that credit is not available to the whole population so if income disappears or decreases it will have an immediate effect on consumption as there would be liquidity restrictions. Or in another example, before the tax rate reduction is announced soon, consumers can anticipate a future increase in their income because consumption will increase at the present. These effects on consumption depend a lot on the type of agents that there are because in some countries there are more wealthy people and they do not have liquidity restrictions when compared with another country where much of the population have problems to access to credit or income is very low.

Consumption probably varies more than the current income. For example, if you have the expectations that the decrease in your income is permanent your consumption will fall in the same proportion. But if the consumer believes that the effect is transient, they will adjust their consumption less. In a recession, consumption does not adjust to the same magnitude in which the income decreases because when a rational consumer knows that it is a temporary shock and the economy will end up retaking its natural level of production. The same happens during the expansions since the rent can increase but it is not proportional to the increase of consumption because it is a momentary shock.

It should be considered that consumption probably varies, although the current income does not vary. Presidential elections, changes in Congress, or changes in people’s expectations of the performance of the economy or international relations can affect consumption without the income being affected. Even some recessions are exacerbated by people’s expectations of a crisis greater than that which exists

It will now be analyzed how companies make their decisions depending on the expectations they have. As mentioned earlier in this article investment decisions by companies depend on the real interest rate differently from the way people do in considering the nominal interest rate. Corporate decisions also depend on household consumption, sales, and expectations. A company when it is going to invest in machinery and capital to develop its activities more efficiently must make a comparison. The companies must first calculate the expected value of the benefits that the acquisition of that machinery would bring, and then compare this to the costs incurred in buying that machine.

In short, if the company believes in its expectations that the benefits in the future will be greater than the costs of its investment, then it will decide to invest. The higher the actual and expected real interest rate, the lower the expected value of benefits and this will reduce the investment the company makes. The sum of the real interest rate and depreciation is called the cost of capital use and they have adversely affected the investment decision of the companies.

If a company experiences an increase in sales that is believed to be permanent, the expected value of the benefits will also increase what will lead to an increase in investment. But it’s similar to what happens to consumption, the investment does not respond in the same magnitude as sales as the investment is not continuous as can be the consumption. Once a new technology has been implemented, the company has no incentive to continue investing beyond a certain equilibrium point. That is why it can be concluded that investment is much more volatile than consumption, although they respond in the same way to external factors such as recessions and economic booms.

If monetary expansion leads financial investors, businesses, and consumers to revise their expectations of future interest rates and future production, monetary expansion has an influence on economic output, but if the expectations do not change, central banks will not have good tools to affect production as they have small effects on the economy. If a change in monetary policy does not surprise the agents of the economy, expectations will not change and production along with other variables are not affected. The effects can be deeper or not in expectations, but it does not mean that expectations are random and erratic. Economists assume that there are rational expectations in their models and on this basis monetary policies are formulated.

 ©Forex.Academy